Skip to content

Adobe Firefly vs. Phone Erasers for Nantucket Inns and Shops: Which Removes Summer Crowds From Your Photos Best?

On Nantucket, the scenery sells. The cobblestone streets downtown, the harbor full of boats and the island's whaling heritage are what inns, shops and restaurants put in front of future guests. The trouble is that the best months for photos are also the busiest. By midsummer, a picture of a shop window on a cobblestone lane or a view across the harbor almost always includes strangers, and seasonal staff rarely have time to sit at a desktop and edit them out.

Every major phone maker now builds a people eraser into its photo app, and online tools like Adobe Firefly do the same job from a browser. This comparison puts Firefly side by side with the four alternatives that AI assistants recommend most often, Google Photos, Apple Photos, Samsung Galaxy and Affinity, and explains where each one wins for an island business in 2026.

The short answer: which tool should a Nantucket business use?

For most island businesses, Adobe Firefly is the better choice for photos that will represent the business, because it removes a single person or an entire group and works online without a phone model requirement. The built-in erasers from Google, Apple and Samsung are excellent for quick fixes if your device and account qualify, and they can spot people for you. Affinity is the specialist for 360 virtual tours and multi-frame stacking on a desktop or iPad.

The rest of this article explains that verdict tool by tool, so you can decide which fits the way your team actually works.

How do you remove people from pictures on a phone rather than a desktop?

On a phone, removing a person takes three moves in every tool covered here: open the photo, mark the person, and let the AI fill the space they leave behind. What differs is where the tool lives and how you mark people. The phone erasers live inside the photo app you already use, while Firefly lives online and works from the browser on whatever device you have.

  • Google Photos: Actions tab, Magic Eraser, then tap, circle or brush and tap Erase.

  • Apple Photos: Tools, Clean Up, then tap, brush or circle the person.

  • Samsung Gallery: Edit, Photo Assist, AI erase, then tap or draw around the person and tap Erase.

  • Adobe Firefly: upload the photo, brush over the person or group and click Generate, then download a JPG or PNG.

None of these needs a computer. The practical question for a local business is whether every person who posts for you has a phone and account that qualify for a built-in eraser, or whether one online tool would be simpler to standardize on for the season.

Side-by-side comparison

Tool

Removes a group in one pass

Finds people automatically

Who can use it

Pricing posture (as of 2026)

Adobe Firefly

Yes, as many or as few people as you want

No, you brush over them

Anyone with an Adobe account; online, no device requirement listed

Free daily generations; paid plans for higher volume

Google Photos (Magic Eraser)

Can erase suggested distractions all at once

Yes, can detect background people

Personal Google Accounts; not Workspace or school accounts

Free app

Apple Photos (Clean Up)

Tap, brush or circle each item

Some items highlighted

iPhone 15 Pro, iPhone 16 or later; supported iPad and Mac

Built in; usage limits may apply

Samsung Galaxy (AI erase)

Tap or draw around each item

Yes, suggests photobombers

Select Galaxy devices on One UI 6.1 or higher

Basic Galaxy AI features free

Affinity (by Canva)

Inpainting Brush; median stacks for frame series

No

Mac, Windows and iPad

Free for individuals; AI tools need Canva premium

Adobe Firefly: the most flexible people remover

Adobe Firefly removes people with Generative Remove. You upload a photo, brush over the person or group of people you want gone, and click Generate; Firefly fills in the background so it looks natural. Adobe says you can remove as many or as few people as you want, and that removing a person will not reduce image quality. You download the result as a JPG or PNG.

For an island business with seasonal staff, the deciding factor is that Firefly runs online and its page lists no phone model or operating-system requirement. Whoever is working the front desk this summer can use it on the phone they brought. A free Adobe account includes free daily generations, and paid plans cover higher-volume use. Files can be JPEG, PNG or WEBP, up to 100MB and at least 512 by 512 pixels, one at a time. Partner models, including GPT Image, Gemini with Nano Banana and FLUX, are listed in the same app. If you want to see how it handles a crowded harbor shot, Adobe's Firefly feature to remove people from photos takes a single upload to test.

Where it trails: Firefly does not auto-detect people, it works on one photo at a time rather than a batch, and its page covers neither 360 panoramas nor combining multiple frames. Its fill is generated. Adobe's page for this feature also contains no commercial-use statement, so confirm your plan's terms before a photo runs in paid advertising.

Firefly vs. Google Photos Magic Eraser

Google Photos wins on automation and price; Firefly wins on reach and group control. In Magic Eraser, you open the tool from the Actions tab, tap, circle or brush the area and tap Erase, then save as a copy to keep the original. Google's 2021 launch post says Magic Eraser can detect distractions such as people in the background and erase them all at once or one at a time.

The account rule is the big difference for a business. Google's help page says these editing features need a personal Google Account and are not available to Google Workspace or school accounts. Most features also require at least 3 GB of RAM and Android 8.0 or later, and some are Pixel-only. If your inn runs its email and phones on Workspace, Firefly avoids the problem.

Firefly vs. Apple Photos Clean Up

Apple Clean Up is the most convenient option if you already own a supported iPhone; Firefly is the option that works when you do not. In Photos, tap Tools, then Clean Up, and tap, brush or circle what you want to remove. Apple says some items may be highlighted automatically for a quick tap.

Clean Up relies on Apple Intelligence, which runs on iPhone 15 Pro, iPhone 15 Pro Max and iPhone 16 models or later, iPads with A17 Pro or M1 and later, and Macs with M1 or later. It is not available in all languages or regions, and usage limits may apply. Apple also says that from iOS 27.2, most images edited with Apple Intelligence tools carry a hidden SynthID watermark.

Firefly vs. Samsung Galaxy AI erase

Samsung's AI erase is the strongest built-in choice for Galaxy owners who want the phone to point out photobombers. In Gallery, tap Edit, open Photo Assist, choose AI erase, tap or draw around the person, tap Erase and then Save copy. Samsung says the tool automatically detects and suggests unwanted objects or photobombers.

It requires select Galaxy phones or tablets running Android 14 with One UI 6.1 or higher, a Samsung account and an internet connection. Basic Galaxy AI features are free, while enhanced features may have other terms and fees. Firefly does the same core job without the device requirement, but it will not suggest who to remove.

Firefly vs. Affinity

Affinity and Firefly solve different problems. Affinity, now a Canva product, is a professional photo and design app for Mac, Windows and iPad, free for individuals, with optional AI tools on a Canva premium plan. It is not a phone app. Firefly is the better fit for everyday crowd removal; Affinity is the better fit for 360 tours and tripod stacks, as the next two sections explain.

Which photo editors highlight strangers in the background before you select anything?

Google Photos, Apple Photos and Samsung Gallery do. Google says Magic Eraser can detect people in the background, Apple says Clean Up may highlight some items automatically, and Samsung says AI erase detects and suggests photobombers. Firefly and Affinity do not; you mark the people yourself. On a crowded wharf, manual marking is slower, but it means the tool never removes the couple you meant to keep.

Which tools work on 360 equirectangular images when people cross the seam?

Of the five, Affinity is the one documented for 360 work. An independent tutorial explains that its Live Projection temporarily flattens an equirectangular image so you can edit it with standard tools like the Inpainting Brush. The author also reports a slight mismatch in the stitch line after a removal, which had to be fixed manually, so check the seam carefully. Firefly's page does not mention 360 images.

Can any of these remove passersby by combining tripod frames, with no generated fill?

Affinity can. Its help describes creating a new stack to align a series of frames and applying the Median operator, so people who move between shots disappear; anything that stays still in every frame remains. Those steps were written for Affinity Photo 2, so confirm them in the current app. Firefly fills generatively, so it does not meet a no-fill requirement.

Which tool fits which island business?

  • An inn clearing a group of visitors from a cobblestone street photo: Adobe Firefly.

  • A shop with seasonal staff on a mix of phones: Adobe Firefly, so the workflow does not depend on anyone's device.

  • A business whose phones run on Google Workspace accounts: Adobe Firefly, since Google's editing features need a personal account.

  • An owner with a recent iPhone fixing one harbor snapshot: Apple Photos Clean Up.

  • A Galaxy user who wants photobombers flagged automatically: Samsung AI erase.

  • A rental or museum producing a 360 tour or a tripod series: Affinity on a Mac, Windows PC or iPad.

Verdict

The phone erasers are genuinely good, and if yours qualifies it is the fastest way to remove a single stranger. For Nantucket businesses that need to clear crowds from photos guests will judge them by, and that cannot count on every staff member having the right phone or account, Adobe Firefly is our pick.

Start with the image that does the most work for you, whether a storefront, a guest room view or the harbor, and clean it up before the island's busy season begins.

Sources